Wednesday, 13 May 2020

The Story of our Family: Generation Four - Charlotte Keeble and the Keebles


THE STORY OF OUR FAMILY

GENERATION FOUR

CHARLOTTE KEEBLE AND THE KEEBLES



James Keeble (b. 1730s) and Mary – my gggggrandparents
            James (b.1757) and Sarah Haggar (b.1762) – my ggggrandparents
John (1801-1870) and Mary Mower (1801-1840) – my gggrandparents
Charlotte (1838/9-1904) and James Tait (1840-1919) -– my ggrandparents
Ada Agnes Tait (1879-1936) and James O’Donoghue (1874-1965) – my grandparents

This is a story of country folk from the eighteenth to the nineteenth century, through the turmoil of the agricultural and industrial revolutions with a few migrations into the Victorian East End.

A gradual transformation of the traditional agricultural system began in Britain in the 18th century. Aspects of this complex period of change, which was not completed until the 19th century, included the reallocation of land ownership to make farms more compact and an increased investment in technical improvements, such as new machinery, better drainage, scientific methods of breeding, and experimentation with new crops and systems of crop rotation.  The enclosure of communal lands into today’s boundaried fields was fundamental to this period.


My great grandmother, Charlotte Keeble, and her family were right in the middle of these changes, but it does not appear that the industrial revolution, ie factory work, really affected her family much.  Most of them remained in agriculture as labourers.



The villages of Baylham (see left) and Nettlestead (see later) in Suffolk are at the heart of this story and while marriage extended the residential places, it wasn’t really by much.  Just like in rural Ireland people met their future spouses, or had their matches made, within a very small geographic area.


In 1841, the Keeble name was very geographically concentrated: Suffolk 328 people, Essex 200, London 168 with minimal numbers elsewhere.  By 1911 this distribution had moved to: Suffolk 874 people, Essex 552, London 708.   While this might seem to make the task of tracing them easier, the use of the same Christian names actually means it’s quite testing to know whether one has the right James or Mary or whatever.



I had to consider in what order to tackle this family as I have taken it quite a long way back.  I will tell Charlotte’s story first and then go back through her siblings followed by the earlier generations.


Charlotte’s story


Charlotte Keeble was born in Baylham, in 1839, and baptised at Baylham St Peters (see left).  The village is about seven miles north west of Ipswich and in the C of E deanery of Bosmere. 

Her father John was an agricultural labourer and her mother was Mary Mower.  They were married in 1823 in Baylham.  I am guessing a bit to say Mary was born in 1799 in nearby Elmsett to a Robert and Abigail.  She died in 1840.

Charlotte was the youngest of eight children.  Other Keebles in the village in 1841 were her grandmother, Sarah, age 75, and her uncle William and his family.

By 1851 the family had moved to Great Blakenham, and ten years later Charlotte was employed as a servant in the household of a woollen draper in Ipswich.

Charlotte was living in Plaistow, West Ham in 1871 with a George Reed and two children, Mary b.1868 and Augustus b.1869.  George was a carpenter and was born in Gravesend, Kent. I have been unable to find a marriage, but George died in 1874 leaving Charlotte with two little kids.  Non-married relationships were reasonably common in the 19th century; perhaps Charlotte was not the marrying kind.  Her children, however, took the Reed name.

On Ada’s birth certificate in 1879, her mother is described as Charlotte Tait, late Reed formerly Keeble, but two years later, in the 1881 census, she is described as Charlotte Phillips (and Ada also as Phillips, presumably because her parents weren’t married yet).  Charlotte is shown as housekeeper and a widow.  Perhaps after George Reed died Charlotte set up house with a Mr Phillips before meeting James.  Or perhaps it was just an enumerator’s cock up.  It’s all rather confusing.  The census enumerator was the person who appeared at your door to record who lived at your house.  

My suspicion is that she was not married to either of these gentlemen, as it took four years from Ada’s birth for her to marry James Tait - in 1884 at St Paul’s Bow Common (right).

I wondered what happened to Charlotte’s Reed children.  Mary Emma (Charlotte’s mother and sister’s names) was born in Plaistow and Augustus George in West Ham. 

Mary Emma’s story was uncomfortable for a while.  In 1881 she was recorded as a visitor (with surname Reeve, I am not sure the enumerator was concentrating!) in the Tait household.  Odd I thought, why not as Charlotte’s daughter like Ada.   In 1891 Mary was in the Poplar Workhouse (see left) working as a machinist and in the same year gave birth to a boy, Henry.  Unmarried pregnant
women were often disowned by their families and the workhouse became their only refuge.  I suspect that is what happened.  Her life was clearly complicated, and then it improved as in 1895 she married Sydney Leech in Poplar and they had a number of children.  She worked as a dressmaker.  Henry is shown as a son rather than stepson so he was alright too, but the 1911 census shows that of the seven children Mary had, only four survived.

Augustus is a virtual blank in terms of knowledge of his life.  I know his birth and his death date, 1947 in East Ham, but nothing in between except that he was an engine driver on tugboats.  He’s out there in the records somewhere, but I haven’t found him yet.

Charlotte died in the last quarter of 1904, almost certainly in 18 Cotton Street.

The village of Baylham and the life of an agricultural labourer

It was recorded in the Domesday Book (1086) as Beleham.  So its history goes a long way back.  But our period is the 18th and 19th centuries when the process of enclosure changed humble country folk’s lives for ever.

Enclosure was the division or consolidation of communal fields, meadows, pastures, and other arable lands in western Europe into the carefully delineated and individually owned and managed farm plots of modern times. Before enclosure, much farmland existed in the form of numerous, dispersed strips under the control of individual cultivators only during the growing season and until harvesting was completed for a given year. Thereafter, and until the next growing season, the land was at the disposal of the community for grazing by the village livestock and for other purposes. To enclose land was to put a hedge or fence around a portion of this open land and thus prevent the exercise of common grazing and other rights over it.

In England the movement for enclosure began in the 12th century and proceeded rapidly in the period 1450–1640, when the purpose was mainly to increase the amount of full-time pasturage available to manorial lords. Much also occurred in the period from 1750 to 1860, when it was done for the sake of agricultural efficiency. By the end of the 19th century the process of the enclosure of common lands was virtually complete.

John Clare (1793–1864) was an English Romantic poet, who grew up in a village near Peterborough. The son of a farm labourer, he became known for his celebrations of the English countryside and sorrows at its disruption.  He finished school at 11 and was self-taught.  As a nature lover and inveterate rambler, I like his stuff.  The Cottager is relevant to our story and I have included the first sixteen lines below. 

True as the church clock hand the hour pursues
He plods about his toils and reads the news,
And at the blacksmith's shop his hour will stand
To talk of 'Lunun' as a foreign land.
For from his cottage door in peace or strife
He neer went fifty miles in all his life.
His knowledge with old notions still combined
Is twenty years behind the march of mind.
He views new knowledge with suspicious eyes
And thinks it blasphemy to be so wise.
On steam's almighty tales he wondering looks
As witchcraft gleaned from old blackletter books.
Life gave him comfort but denied him wealth,
He toils in quiet and enjoys his health,
He smokes a pipe at night and drinks his beer
And runs no scores on tavern screens to clear
.


After this somewhat sanitised description of one single man’s rural life, what of a family’s accommodation?

The Rev. James Fraser, afterwards Bishop of Manchester, one of the Assistant Commissioners in the inquiry made in 1867-68 into the conditions of the agricultural labour (an inquiry nominally confined to the employment of women and children, but really extending to the whole subject), reports that "the majority of" cottages that exist in rural parishes are deficient in almost every requisite that should constitute a home for a Christian family in a civilised community. They are deficient in bedroom accommodation, very few having three chambers, and in some chambers the larger proportion only one. They are deficient in drainage and sanitary arrangements; they are conveniences as they have are often so situated as to become nuisances; they are full enough of draughts to generate any amount of rheumatism; and in many instances are lamentably dilapidated and out of repair.

"It is impossible to exaggerate the ill effects of such a state of things in every aspect, physical, social, economical, moral, intellectual. Physically, a ruinous, ill-drained cottage, cribbed, cabin'd, confined, and overcrowded, generates any amount of disease, fevers of every type, catarrh, rheumatism, as well as intensifies to the utmost that tendency to scrofula (disease of the lymph nodes) and phthisis (tuberculosis) which, from their frequent intermarriages and their low diet, abound so largely among the poor.

"The moral consequences are fearful to contemplate. … Modesty must be an unknown virtue, decency an unimaginable thing, where in one small chamber … two and sometimes three generations are herded promiscuously, … where the whole atmosphere is sensual, and human nature is degraded into something below the level of the swine. It is a hideous picture, and the picture is drawn from life." 
If that was in the mid-19th century what must it have been like in the 18th?  These conditions were not much different from our ancestors in North Kerry.  Our Keebles were certainly not very long lived, although I have not done a complete search on death dates.

In 1841 Baylham had 275 residents, eight farms and almost all the employment was driven by them
with support trades of miller, gamekeepers x 4, thatcher, shopkeeper, grocer, wheelwright, blacksmith, shoemaker and brickmaker.  It was an archetype self-sufficient country village and everyone was born in Suffolk.  No school is separately identified but I imagine it was attached to the rectory.  Produce/animals would have been taken to Needham Market or Great Blakenham for sale, both are about two miles from Baylham.  The main items were cereals (including wheat, barley, and oats), sugar beets, cattle, and pigs.

In 1870-72, John Marius Wilson's Imperial Gazetteer of England and Wales described the village like this:

BAYLHAM, a parish in Bosmere district, Suffolk; on the river Gipping and the Eastern Union railway, 1 mile NNW of Claydon station, and 7 NW by W of Ipswich. Post Town Claydon, under Ipswich. Acres, 1,332. Real property, £2,276. Pop., 327. Houses, 65. The property is all in one estate. The living is a rectory in the diocese of Norwich. Value, £256. Patron, W. Downes, Esq. The church is old but good.
There are still some very historic buildings in the village.
Baylham Hall, an early 17th century manor house with alterations from later 17th to mid-19th centuries, which is now a Grade II listed building.   The house stands within a partly infilled mediaeval moat.   It is now a rare breeds farm open to the public.
Baylham Mill comprises a watermill and mill house. The house is in two sections - early 16th century or earlier, and mid-19th century.  The mill is of the early or mid-19th century.  This is also Grade II listed
Parts of Baylham Church date back to the early 1100s and then bits from the centuries thereafter. In 1870-1, the Rector at the time (the Revd W E Downes referenced above) was determined to restore the church, which was reported to have suffered from ‘neglect and injudicious care’.  The work cost £1000 of which 50% was paid for by the Acton family who were the lords of the manor.



The River Gipping flows through the village.  The source is in the village of Mendlesham Green about 7.5 miles north east. It is fed by waters drained from fields.





How did the characteristics of the village change over the next 50 years?  By 1891 there were 6 (vs 8) farms.  The same trades were still there but there was also a separate farrier, two farm bailiffs, a scrap collector/sweep and a pork butcher.  And there was a teacher for the Governor’s School.

There was only one Keeble family in the village by 1881 and they were unrelated to ours as far as I can see.

The number of people living in the village today hasn’t changed much at all – 250 (25 less than in 1841)

Charlotte’s parents and siblings

John Keeble (1801-70) and Mary Mower (1799-1840) - my gggrandparents
            Mary Harriett (b.& d.1823)
            Eliza (1826-69) and Thomas Buckingham (1825- ) from Claydon
            Emma (1828- ) and George Manby (1824- ) from Creeting St Mary
            John (1830- ) and Susan Whiting (1830- ) from Leiston near coast
            Caroline (1832- ) and John Buckle (1822- ) from Earl Stonham
            James (1834- ) and Margariet (1846- ) from Co. Wicklow, Ireland
            Ann (1836- ) and Robert Squirrel (1829- ) from Darmsden
            Charlotte (1838- ) and George Reed (1840- ) 
                                          and James Tait (1840- ) – my ggrandparents

It was a pretty good record to only lose one child to an early death.

Apart from the two indicated in italics and, of course, Charlotte who went to London, as far as I can see all the children met, married and stayed in the area in places 3-4 miles from Baylham.  James’s Irish wife Margariet probably came over for the annual hiring of Irish farm workers to help with the harvest, and stayed.

All the men remained agricultural labourers.  Of the children James added grocer and gardener to his repertoire, and John rose up the ranks to farm 170 acres on his own account.

Charlotte’s ancestors

James Keeble (b.1730s) of Nettlestead and Mary (b.1730s)– my gggggrandparents
James Keeble (1757- ) and Sarah Haggar (1762- ) – my ggggrandparents
                        James (1782-3) buried in Nettlestead
                        Sarah (1784- ) and John Caley (1781- ) from Yaxley
                        Elizabeth (1786- ) and John James from Barking
                        James (1788- ) and Sarah Barrell
                                                 and Mary Morris (1785- ) from Debenham
William (1790- ) and Charlotte Barrell (1801- ) from Nettlestead
                                        and Amy Holland (1803- ) from Somersham
                        Charlotte (1800-22)
                        John (1801-70) and Mary Mower (1799-1840) - my gggrandparents
I have concluded that James Keeble (b.1757) was from Nettlestead, a small, dispersed village on the northern outskirts of Somersham and less than two miles from Baylham.  For some reason it is not shown on the A-Z map scan included earlier; I have no idea why.
This was where the family resided in the first half of the 18th century.  I can’t be absolutely certain that I have the right family, but there are a number of pointers.  
James and Sarah were married in Baylham in 1782.  Their first son, James (1782-3), died young and was buried in Nettlestead.  As you see above, they named a later son James which, at a time when infant mortality was high, happened quite often.
My ggggrandfather James was the son of James Keeble and a Mary.  This couple had thirteen children in Nettlestead between 1756 and 1777.  Many of their Christian names are repeated over later generations.  I have shown all their children in Appendix One.

The village of Nettlestead

In Nettlestead there were two manor houses: The Chace and High Hall.  Both are shown on the attached old map.  Our agricultural labourer ancestors may well have worked on one or both of them.
The Chace belonged to the Earls of Richmond and then passed over the centuries to Peter II, the Count of Savoy, Richard de Tiptoft, the Despencers and the Wentworths. It became Nettlestead Hall (shown as such on map) under the ownership of the latter family and retains an ancient gateway, bearing the arms of the Wentworths. From the 13th to the 16th centuries the Nettlestead families were patrons of the house of friars minor in Ipswich.  It is now called Nettlestead Chace and is Grade II listed.
What was a manor house?  During the European Middle Ages, it was the dwelling of the lord of the manor or his residential bailiff and administrative centre of the feudal estate. The medieval manor was generally fortified to the degree of peaceful settlement of the country or region in which it was located. The manor house was the centre of secular village life, and its great hall was the scene of the manorial court and the place of assembly of the tenantry. The particular character of the manor house is most clearly represented in England and France, but under different names similar dwellings of feudal overlords existed in all countries wherein the manorial system developed.  
By the 18th century it was where the local major landlord lived, who will have employed many local
people.

High Hall dates back to the 16th Century and was built by Huguenots who had fled from France during series of religious persecutions.  It is Grade II listed.



The Church of St Mary is mainly dated to around 1500, but with the core from the 12th century and later.  There are some very historic decorations and the font is early 15th century. The church is Grade I listed.







Located to the north-west of Ipswich and 11 miles from Stowmarket, the village’s  population in 2005 was 90.

The Keeble name

Suffolk shows the largest proportion (35%) of Keebles in England in 1891.  Originally the name was from South Germany as Kübel, a metonymic (the substitution of an associated thing) occupational name for a cooper, from Middle High German kübel which means a ‘tub’ or a ‘vat’.


Sources & acknowledgements
https://www.britannica.com/topic/agricultural-revolution
https://www.britannica.com/place/Mid-Suffolk
https://catalogue.millsarchive.org/watermill-baylham?page=2&sort=lastUpdated&sortDir=desc&listLimit=20
https://your-family-history.com/surname/k/keeble/
https://portoflondonstudy.wordpress.com/2017/11/
https://www.visionofbritain.org.uk/place/7023
https://www.britannica.com/topic/enclosure
https://www.flickr.com/photos/john_fielding/20461444600
https://britishlistedbuildings.co.uk/101033260-baylham-watermill-and-mill-house-baylham
Agricultural worker wearing a smock, University of Reading
https://www.britannica.com/technology/manor-house
https://britishlistedbuildings.co.uk/101251559-nettlestead-chace-nettlestead#.XrwpJG5FxPY


Appendix One

The Keebles of Nettlestead


James Keeble (b.1730s) and Mary (b.1730s) of Nettlestead – my gggggrandparents
            Mary (b.1756)
James (b.1757)
Samuel (b.1759)
Elizabeth (b.1761)
Sarah (b.1765)
John (b.1766)
Martha (1766-67)
Ann (1768-74)
Joseph (b.1769) and Martha Pratt (b.1771)
            Joseph (1796-97))
William (1797-98))
Susannah (b.1798)
Mary (b.& d.1800)
Mary (b.1802)
Lucy (b.1802)
Joseph (b.1804)
Harriot (b.1816)
Frederick (b.1814)
            Lydia (b.1770)
Nathaniel (b.& d.1772)
Amy (b.1773)
Jeremiah (b.1777)

To be noted

·       - the use of the same name for a future child after first child has died
·       - names repeated in next two generations: Mary, James, Elizabeth, Sarah, John, Martha, Ann, William, Harriot, Frederick.

Saturday, 18 April 2020

The Story of our family - Generation Four: James Tait and the Taits


THE STORY OF OUR FAMILY

GENERATION FOUR

JAMES TAIT AND THE TAITS


Charles Tait (1801-75) and Agnes Smith (1804- ) – gggrandparents       
           William (1826-)
Robert (1829-1904)
            Jess (1830-)
            Henry (1833-)
            Georgina (1836-1909)
            Charles (1837-)
            James (1840-1919) and Charlotte Keeble (1839-1904) – ggrandparents
                       Ada Agnes (1879-1936) & James O’Donoghue (1874-1965) - grandparents

This blog continues the story of Ada Agnes Tait’s family, taking us to the north east of Scotland to the town of Arbroath.

Sadly I am unable to upload some of the great historic photographs of the area, as the copyright holder refused my request to use three or four of them.  So I have provided a link to the ones I would have used.  

James Tait (1840-1919) – my ggrandfather

Ada Agnes’s father, James was born in 1840 in Arbroath, Forfarshire (now Angus), Scotland to Charles Tait, a pilot, and Agnes Smith.  They lived in a street called Old Shore Head.  It is still there down near the harbour.  This is what it looked like in 1895
https://tour-scotland-photographs.blogspot.com/2018/09/old-photograph-shorehead-road-by.html

Arbroath is located on the North Sea Coast of Scotland, about 16 miles north east of Dundee and 45 miles south west of Aberdeen.  The town grew considerably during the Industrial Revolution owing to the expansion of firstly the flax and secondly the jute industries plus the engineering sector.  By 1817 Arbroath was Scotland’s biggest sailcloth producer.  From the 18th century shipbuilding and repair were important industries.  A new harbour was built in 1839 and by the 20th century, Arbroath had become one of the larger fishing ports in Scotland.  I have promised myself a trip up there sometime.
https://tour-scotland-photographs.blogspot.com/2010/04/old-photograph-harbour-arbroath.html

By 1861 James was working as a journeyman rope and sail maker.  In that year there appear to have been three shipbuilders in the town, so presumably he ranged between them.  During James’s time there was a serious accident.  In 1863 the barque Elmgrove, on launch, fell on her starboard side, wobbled and righted itself before capsizing with thirty men and boys aboard. All managed to scramble on top or swim to safety, only one boy slightly injured by a chain. 

In 1865 James married Mary Ann Simpson in Arbroath in the Wesleyan Methodist Church.

John Wesley visited Arbroath a total of 15 times. He opened this octagonal chapel in 1772. Nicknamed the 'Totum Kirkie' from 'totum', an eight-sided spinning top, and 'kirk', being the Scottish word for church. The premises contain a number of interesting features including stained glass windows showing the intimate relationship between life on the sea and this church's community. It was listed in 1971.

Mary Ann’s parents were Robert Simpson and Mary Smart.  Robert was a baker.  Mary Ann was born in 1845.

James and Mary Ann had two children in Arbroath: Mary Jane (1867-); James (1870-).  Then they moved to London, and in 1871 were in 18 Burcham Street, Poplar.  A third child, Margaret, was born in 1874.  

Mary Ann died in 1876, and by 1881 James was living with Charlotte Phillips (née Keeble) in 12 Sturry Street.  They were married in the same year.  Ada Agnes had been born two years before in 1879.  By 1883 they had moved to 66 Cotton Street and Albert Edward was born that year.  By 1891 they had relocated to 18 Cotton Street, just down the road from our O’Donoghues.  and were still there in 1901 with an 18-year-old son, Albert, and Lily, described as a daughter, but she was Charlotte’s from an earlier relationship to be described in the next blog.  Charlotte’s relationships were really quite hard to get my head round, which is one reason why she is worthy of a separate article.

Charlotte died in 1904 and by 1908 James had married again.  Alice Kerr was from Sunderland and 21 years younger than him.  They were living at 6 Clifton Road, Canning Town in 1911.

James seems to have changed the nature of his work over the years as sometimes he is described as a sailmaker and at others as a general labourer.  Like so many on the docks, employment was precarious and subject to the daily call up at the dock gates.

The best description I have of him was from Kate Hosford (née Phillips) who grew up next door to our lot.  She said that he was a big man with a long white beard and that when he and Thomas O’Donoghue, my great grandfather, got together and started to sing it was quite something.  After my father died, I found some very old sheets of a traditional Irish song – Shamus O’Brien.  I have always wondered if this was his memory of his childhood, hearing his family singing.  I’ve attached the words at Appendix One.

I was also told by someone that Gaelic was to be heard in the house.  Thomas would certainly have spoken the language, perhaps James spoke the Scottish version.  They are a bit different, but speakers of either can easily understand each other.

James Tait died in 1919 in Poplar – he was 79.

Now to look at his father and James’s siblings…

Charles Tait (1801-75) and Agnes Smith (1804- ) – gggrandparents

Charles Tait was born in around 1801 in St Vigeans, in his day a small village and parish immediately
north of Arbroath.  The old village consisted of a single street of red sandstone cottages flanking the foot of the church mound.  The church (right) has undergone some changes since Charles’s time.  Today St Vigeans has been absorbed within the growth of Arbroath.

Charles and Agnes married in Arbroath in 1829 in the Church of Scotland.  As shown above they had seven children.  As their eldest, William, was born before Charles and Agnes were married I wondered if he was the child of an earlier marriage for Charles, but I have not found one so must conclude he was born ‘out of wedlock’.

Illegitimacy in Scotland ran higher than in England and Wales in the nineteenth century: in 1859 6.5 per cent of births in England and Wales, but 9 per cent in Scotland, were illegitimate.  This statistic, called the illegitimacy ratio, disguises a great deal of variation among smaller localities, particularly in the case of Scotland where only 3.3 out of every hundred births in Orkney were illegitimate, but in the North Eastern counties of Nairn, Elgin, Banff, Aberdeen and Kincardine on average over 15 per cent of births were born outside marriage.

In 1841 two families of Smiths were living each side of our couple.  Peter Smith (age 50) was a Fish Manager; his sons Robert (age 25) and Thomas (age 20) were pilots.  John Smith (also age 50) is another pilot.  Peter and John were probably Agnes’s (age 40) siblings.

A pilot is a sailor who manoeuvres ships through dangerous or congested waters, such as harbours or river mouths. They are navigational experts possessing knowledge of the particular waterway such as its depth, currents, and hazards.  This is a very skilled job and I imagine that Charles was a fisherman before he gained the necessary experience.

Agnes Smith, Charles’s wife, may have been born in Arbroath either

            in 1796 to David Smith (a butcher) and Margaret Swankie or  
-                  in 1804 to David Smith (a writer) and Agnes Neish


The reason I am not sure as to date is that in the 1841 census Charles and Agnes are both said to be age 40.  By 1851 Agnes was recorded as age 55 i.e 5 years older than Charles and in 1861 as 6 years older.  I suspect Agnes didn’t tell Charles her correct age until after 1851.  I wonder what he said!  This points to the 1796 birth parents as the possible ones, but none of her children were named David or Margaret whereas Agnes was used, so we are left wondering.  I discuss Scottish naming practices and our family later.

Charles was still living by himself at 15 Old Shorehead in 1861; he was a widower as Agnes had died in the 1860s. By 1875 he had also gone; he is buried in the Western Cemetery in Arbroath.  I must try and find it.

Charles & Agnes’s children

As you will see although Charles was a pilot/fisherman many of his family were employed in the flax industry.  There are all sorts of different jobs in the records.  I will mention a few as we proceed.    I am listing their children’s names for reasons that will appear later.

Their eldest son, William (1826-), was employed as a flax dresser in 1841, a worker who separated the coarse part of flax or hemp with a hackle (a very large comb); they were also known as hacklers.  One of my mother’s ancestors in the late 18th/early 19th century was a hackler in Norfolk.  By 1851 all of Charles and Agnes's children, bar James (still at school) were employed in the flax industry.  But William had vanished from the records.  I checked to see if he had died or emigrated to USA or Australia without success. 

Robert (1829-1904) married Jessie Stuart/Stewart in 1852 and the children - Jacob, Jessie, Henry & Robert – followed. Then, I think, Jessie died (and he married Isabella (also Elizabeth) Johnston with whom he had another five – Mary Johnston, Charles, Isabella, Agnes Smith & Alexander Wood.  I have been in contact with a descendant of Mary Johnston in the US.

You will have noticed the second names that look like surnames.  This is a very early/mid-19th century thing. They are not today’s double-barrelled surnames ie Smith-O’Donoghue, but are true Christian names.  Their usage can be based on a number of circumstances.

It was common to use the mother’s or one of the child’s grandmothers’ maiden names.  We can see this above with Johnston (mother) and Smith (grandmother).  This also extended on rarer occasions back to the parents’ grandparents.  But it might also be the surname of the parish priest who baptised the child.

Robert’s jobs ranged from weaver to flax mill bleacher to yarn bundler.  In 1861 the family was living in 30 East Mill Wynd, Arbroath.  This is what the street looked like, not sure exactly when but probably in early 1900s judging by the lamp and the state of the street surface. A wynd is a narrow street or alley leading off a major thoroughfare in Scotland and Northern England; based on Old Norse venda.
https://www.scran.ac.uk/database/record.php?usi=000-000-150-567-C

Jessie (1830-) married James Bell in Arbroath and seven children arose: Ann Leuchars (James’s
mother), Agnes Smith (grandmother), Jessie, Jane, Jemima, Alexander Smith (grandmother) & William.  James was a flax canvas weaver on the power loom.  Again rather later in time but picture is at least representative of a flax mill

Henry (1830-) appears to have died young in the 1840s.  Well, I can’t find him

Georgina (1835-1909) was six years older than her husband, John McMillan, an Irishman from Ulster.  They were married in Arbroath in 1865 and had at least five children: John, Robert, Mary, Jane & Jessie.

In 1871 they were living in Elm Bank Cottage in St Vigeans where John was a domestic servant in the household of Andrew Lowson (1813-1897), the most important mill owner in the town. He was described as a “striking and loveable person”, and by 1864 had twice the horsepower at his disposal and employed twice the number of workers as his nearest competitor.  He employed one thousand people.  Baltic Works is shown left.


The main house Elm Bank is now a Category B listed building.  It is described as a small two-storey
classic mansion house, ashlar and slate, built around 1830, with extensive addition in the mid-19th century.

It all sounds very Downton Abbey as the family employed the following staff: coachman, gatekeeper, cook, table maid, house maid, lady’s maid, washerwoman, gardener and a general domestic servant (John).

By 1881, however, they were back in the town and Elm Bank Cottage doesn’t seem to exist anymore…strange.  She returned to flax spinning and John was a labourer.  They lived in 10 High Street from at least 1891 and this picture is of the High Street in the 1890s.
http://www.arbroathtimeline.moonfruit.com/1890-1899/4518446716  

Georgina died in 1909 and was buried in the Eastern Cemetery.

Charles (1837-) was living with his father until 1851, working as a machine flax dresser.  By 1861 he had gone somewhere else, but where?  It is possible that he had died as there is a burial of a Charles in 1868 in Arbroath, but where was he for those seventeen years?  

Looking outside the UK, did he emigrate?  There is a Charles b.1840 in Massachusetts in 1870 but not thereafter.  My best shot is a Charles in Essex in 1901 described as a retired soldier.  Looking through the Forces War Records there are two of them as possibilities in the record for 1861. No idea if they are relevant and I would have to go to the National Archives in Kew to check out their service record.  More work required.

Scottish naming practices

In order to see if we can establish who my gggrandfather, Charles’s, parents and siblings might have been, we need to fall back on naming practices.  

The Scottish ones were much the same as the Irish.  However, the latter first follow the paternal for both sons and daughters before moving to the maternal.

Sons:
First after paternal grandfather
Second after maternal grandfather
Third after father
Fourth after father’s eldest brother

Daughters:
First after maternal grandmother
Second after paternal grandmother
Third after mother
Fourth after mother’s eldest sister

I have read that in about 10% of cases the first and second paternal/maternal are reversed.

Who might gggrandfather Charles’s parents and siblings be?

Those of you less obsessive about family history may be saying ‘Oh lord, what’s he going on about?’, well like TV you can always turn the screen off!  Or just move on to the next section.  This bit is really for me to record my research.

What the naming practices suggest is that Christian names stayed in the family through the 19th century, even if they didn’t follow the sequencing precisely.  

There are records before Charles b.1801 but they are sparse.   I identified two possible parent combinations for Agnes earlier but neither really fit the pattern.

Our couple’s sons in order of birth are William, Robert, Henry, Charles, James.  So Charles’s father ought to be a William and Agnes’s a Robert, or, if we are one of the 10%, vice versa.

Their daughters are Jess and Georgina.  So if the naming practice was being followed Charles’s parents were a William and Georgina; Agnes’s would be Robert and Jess. 

Going right back into the 17th century there is a William Tait who had four children between 1633 and 1648: Isobell, James, Marie, Janet.  He lived in Arbirlot which is about two and a half miles west of Arbroath.

There is a William b.1761 in Arbroath who married a Christian Maver in 1784 and died in 1832. 

But this is all very tenuous, so let’s give up on that route.

We do, however, know Charles and Agnes’s children, so we can test how far they went in following the tradition on the paternal line.

Second son Robert, b.1829 had sons with Jessie Stuart: Jacob, Henry, Robert and a daughter Jessie.  And with Isabella Johnston: Charles & Alexander and daughters Mary, Isabella & Agnes.

First daughter Jess b. 1832 had sons with James Bell: Alexander and William and daughters Ann Leuchars (James’s mother), Agnes Smith (her mother) so in the reversed sequence but at least the right names.  Remember how earlier I said the mothers’ maiden names were used as Christian names.

Second daughter Georgina b.1835 married John McMillan and had sons John & Robert and daughters Mary, Jane & Jessie 

Charles gets one look in and Agnes two, so one has to say…so much for naming practices in the next generation.

But there is a lot of concurrence in the names used for these two generations.  Out of 30 names there are four times Jess(ie); three Robert, Agnes and Mary; two Henry, Charles, James, Alexander & Jane – so three quarters of the total.

Charles was born in 1801 in St Vigeans which was a separate parish in the first half of the century.  There aren’t many other Taits in this period there, so I suspect all these people born or living in St Vigeans are related to him either as uncles/aunts or siblings/cousins.

Uncles/aunts: 

James b. 1770s and Jane Gibb with son James b.1793
Jacob b.1770s and Agnes Brown with sons Henry b.1803, David b.1810, Jacob b.1811, Alexander b.1813 and daughter Elizabeth b.1806

Siblings/cousins:

Ann b.1802, David b.1813

A lot of work to prove nothing – very frustrating!

The Tait name

The Tait name is of Norse/Viking origin derived from teitr meaning glad or cheerful.

The Taits were an armigerous (with a coat of arms) clan who hailed from the area of Innerleithen, a
small town on the Scottish Borders.  Tait was the second most significant name in that town in the 1881 census.  There is a hill nearby called Pirn and this coat of arms is of the Taits of Pirn, possibly from 17th century.

The town first appears in manuscripts in the 12th century so perhaps Taits were there much earlier as today’s form of surnames started to be adopted from about the 12th century.

The counties with the most Taits in the UK 1881 census were Northumberland 1440; Edinburghshire (Midlothian) 1199; Lanarkshire 783; Shetland 528, Durham 521; Forfarshire (Angus) only 160.  It was the 479th most common name.

Arbroath and Inchcape

For the last twelve years of my working life I was employed by a company called Inchcape PLC, which was about 150 years old.  I knew there was a strong Scottish connection, and an Inchcape Rock, but not much else.

I was looking at today’s Arbroath street map and saw an Inchcape Park down by the seafront and looked further.

The Inchcape lighthouse lies 11 miles out to sea off the east coast of Arbroath. It stands on one of the most treacherous submerged reefs in the northern hemisphere and is one of the seven wonders of the Industrial Age.  I think this puts in context the tough job that our Charles Tait had as a port pilot, and why it was necessary.
Thanks to the pioneering spirit of a young engineer, Robert Stevenson, who dreamed of building the impossible, a lighthouse was planned on the 'Rock' that had claimed over 100 lives.
Despite many obstacles, Stevenson never lost faith in his plan, and by February 1811, the lighthouse on Inchcape Rock was finished. It is the oldest, sea-standing lighthouse in the world and today still saves lives.
100 years later, inspired by this pioneering spirit, Inchcape's founder James Lyle MacKay (1852-1932), when awarded a title for his services to industry became the first 'Baron Inchcape of Strathnaver' and so named the company that he led.  He was the second son of James Mackay of Arbroath a well-to-do shipmaster who died in 1862 while crossing the Atlantic.  
Arbroath today
From the visitscotland site

“Arbroath, settled in the 12th century, lies 15 miles to the north east of Dundee.
The attractive old harbour of Arbroath remains in action and long sandy beaches and stunning
sandstone cliffs stretch out on either side of the town. Arbroath Abbey, located near the centre of the town, is also well worth a visit.
The town's most famous product is the Arbroath Smokie, which was first created in the village of Auchmithie. It is line-caught haddock, smoke-cured over smouldering oak chips, and still made here in a number of family-run smokehouses tucked in around the harbour. One of the most approachable and atmospheric is MM Spink's tiny whitewashed premises at 10 Marketgate; chef and cookery writer Rick Stein described the fish here, warm from the smoke, as "a world-class delicacy".
Wander through the huddled cottages of the 'Fit o'the Toon' - the harbour district where the smell of Arbroath smokies usually hangs heavy in the air. Beyond it, the seafront road heads into Victoria Park. At the far end of the road, a path climbs up over the red sandstone cliffs of Whiting Ness, stretching endlessly onto the horizon and eroded into a multitude of inlets, caves and arches that warrant hours of leisurely exploration.”
Looking at the electoral roll for 2003-10 there have been 31 Taits still living in Arbroath in that period, so they are still very much around.





Sources & acknowledgements

https://tour-scotland-photographs.blogspot.com/
https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Elmbank+House,+St+Vigeans,+Arbroath+DD11+4RD/@56.5755244,-2.5938032,14z/data=!4m13!1m7!3m6!1s0x48868d0136a2538b:0x4476fd5dd2d1c8ba!2sElmbank+House,+St+Vigeans,+Arbroath+DD11+4RD!3b1!8m2!3d56.5755106!4d-2.5933446!3m4!1s0x48868d0136a2538b:0x4476fd5dd2d1c8ba!8m2!3d56.5755106!4d-2.5933446
https://www.ancestor.abel.co.uk/Angus/intro.html#tak
http://homepages.rootsweb.com/~steve/namingse.htm
https://www.inchcape.com/en/who-we-are/our-history.html#item-undefined
https://www.visitscotland.com/info/towns-villages/arbroath-p241591
http://britishsurnames.co.uk/surname/tait/1881census



APPENDIX ONE

SHAMUS O'BRIEN

A traditional Irish folksong

Oh, sweet is the smile of the beautiful morn,
As it peeps through the curtain of night;
And the voice of the nightingale singing his tune,
While the stars seem to smile with delight.
Old nature now lingers in silent repose,
And the sweet breath of Summer is calm;
While I sit and wonder if Shamus ever knows
How sad and unhappy I am!

Chorus.
Oh! Shamus O'Brien, why don't you come home?
You don't know how happy I'll be;
I've but one darling wish, and that is that you'd come,
And forever be happy with me!

I'll smile when you smile, and I'll weep when you weep.
And I'll give you a kiss for a kiss;
And all the fond vows that I've made you, I'll keep,
What more can I promise than this?
Does the sea have such bright and such beautiful charms
That your heart will not leave it for me?
oh! why did I let you get out of my arms,
Like a bird that was caged and is free!- Chorus.

Oh! Shamus O'Brien, I'm loving you yet,
And my heart is still trusting and kind;
It was you who first took it. and can you forget
That love for another you'd find?
No! no! if you break it with sorrow and pain,
I'll then have a duty to do:
If you'll bring it to me, I'll mend it again,
And trust it, dear Shamus, to you.- Chorus.